South Africa: Democracy? Plutocracy? Or… Kakistocracy?
Kakistocracy – a real word describing “a system of government run by the worst, least qualified or most unscrupulous citizens” – might be the most accurate term for South Africa’s current political landscape.
Signs of a Failing State
South Africa appears to be devolving into what many fear is becoming another failed African state. The warning signs have been evident for years, buried beneath:
- Endemic government corruption
- Rampant violent crime
- GBV and child abuse epidemics
- Failed parastatals and bankrupt municipalities
Four Critical Incidents That Revealed the Truth
1. Threatening Nando’s Over a Satirical Ad (2009)
The ANC Youth League forced Nando’s to withdraw a commercial parodying Julius Malema, threatening “militant action” against the fast-food chain. This marked an early attack on freedom of expression.
2. Ejecting a BBC Journalist (2010)
Malema illegally expelled BBC reporter John Fisher from a press briefing after being called out for living in luxury while claiming to champion the poor. The incident exposed authoritarian tendencies within the ruling party.
3. The Spear Painting Controversy (2012)
The ANC’s furious reaction to Brett Murray’s satirical painting of Jacob Zuma led to censorship demands, legal threats, and ultimately the artwork’s removal – another blow to artistic freedom.
4. Forcing FNB to Pull an Anti-Corruption Ad (2013)
The ruling party strong-armed First National Bank into withdrawing an advertisement merely for mentioning corruption, demonstrating intolerance for criticism.
A Fundamental Misunderstanding of Democracy
These incidents reveal a troubling pattern: South Africa’s leaders consistently fail to understand that criticism and satire are essential components of a healthy democracy. Instead of embracing accountability, they:
- Suppress dissent
- Censor artistic expression
- Bully critics into submission
Conclusion: Kakistocracy in Action?
The evidence suggests South Africa may indeed be governed by its least qualified citizens – the very definition of kakistocracy. As constitutional democracy erodes, the question remains: Can this trajectory be reversed before complete state failure?
Share your thoughts on South Africa’s political future in the comments below.
This article summarizes an original report from The South African. Read the full analysis here.